|
Published: July 30, 2004
Are you sure?
Atrazine's effects on human health are a major focus of concern.
Atrazine can cause health problems because, even at low levels, it
disrupts hormones, the specialized chemicals that control many
biological processes.
- Atrazine is linked to breast cancer, prostate cancer, ovarian
cancer, and non-Hodgkin's lymphoma.
- Some scientists claim that the chemical can cause sexual
development problems in children approaching puberty.
- Human fetuses are particularly vulnerable, via amniotic fluid,
to the transmission of atrazine.
- A study has found that atrazine could reduce male sperm counts
by as much as fifty percent.
- There are several lawsuits against atrazine's manufacturer,
Syngenta, by employees who worked in the US atrazine plant and now
have prostate cancer.
Notwithstanding these health concerns, some atrazine supporters
point to uncertainties in the link between atrazine and human health
problems.
- Company representatives say that the higher rates of prostate
cancer allegedly linked to atrazine are simply the result of more
advanced and widespread screening procedures detecting illness
that was there to begin with.
- The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and its
Scientific Panel have consistently determined that atrazine is
only a potential carcinogen.
- Atrazine supporters claim that, as of yet, there has been no
"conclusive" research linking atrazine to negative human
health risks, from cancer to sexual development.
The U.S. EPA has established rules making atrazine's primary
manufacturer, Syngenta, solely responsible for testing watersheds for
atrazine levels, requiring that the company only test 3% of high-risk
watersheds. Natural Resources Defense Council, a leading legal
opponent of atrazine, has led an outcry against these rules.
"We are shocked that EPA would abdicate its responsibility to
protect the public and allow the manufacturer to write the
rules. EPA has
concluded that atrazine probably does not cause cancer in humans,
despite the fact that numerous studies show a link between atrazine
and cancer in both humans and animals."
-Jennifer Sass, Senior Scientist, Natural
Resources Defense Council
Now
that you have heard the arguments for both sides of the issue, what is your position on this topic? Should the U.S. ban its most commonly used
herbicide, atrazine?
|
|